SRC: It’s time for the Price Cap Gimmick to be Scrapped

SRC: It’s time for the Price Cap Gimmick to be Scrapped

Price caps won’t be in place this decade says industry group

Sunday 22nd November 2026

 

The Scottish Retail Consortium has called for the Scottish Government to scrap their Food Price Cap gimmick in a detailed response to the official consultation.

 

The consultation closes this coming Tuesday, 24 November. In a 22-page submission sent to Government last week, the leading trade association explains there is no justification for price caps, no evidence they would help, and no mechanism to deliver them this decade - despite the First Minister’s vow to have price caps in place by the end of this year.

 

The SRC argues Scottish Ministers have singularly failed to make the case for price caps and that no evidence has been forthcoming that government is better than the existing hyper competitive grocery market at setting prices. It adds that shoppers would face higher prices for other products out-with the scope of price caps, that the future of less profitable stores could be put at risk, and that price caps could lead to shortages and frictions in stores between customers and staff.

 

Specifically the response explains:

  • Scottish consumers already benefit from the most affordable prices in Western Europe. Many essential items are already sold at or below cost.

  • The proposals and draft legislation are so vague as to make consultation almost meaningless. If progressed Scottish Ministers will need to consult on full legislation, secondary legislation, and pass both through Parliament before allocating a multi-year implementation period. SRC estimates this cannot be done before 2030.

  • Scottish farmers and producers are likely to lose business as cheaper imports replace home-grown products.

  • Enforcing substitution of similar products would compel retailers to develop Scottish-specific categories across most stores. This means reorganizing their entire logistics and store operations which will be immensely costly, reduce consumer choice, and risk product shortages.

The SRC says Scottish Ministers should scrap the blunt price caps notion and instead pursue a more targeted approach to aid less affluent households. Ministers should work with industry to tackle the cost of doing business for grocers and its supply chain. Other nations which brought in price caps were dealing with runaway inflation well into double digits, whilst food inflation here is currently under three percent.

Commenting on the consultation response, Ewan MacDonald-Russell, Deputy Head of the Scottish Retail Consortium, said:

“Over the last seven months Scottish retailers have strived to take every step possible to help struggling shoppers. Millions have been spent keeping down the price of essential goods. Food inflation has stayed under three percent despite the rocketing cost of fuel and energy. In the same period Scottish Ministers have produced a pealy-wally price cap consultation paper which completely fails to make the case they could set prices better than the market.  

 

“The price cap policy may have been conceived as a potty election gimmick. But the negative consequences would be immense. Similar policies elsewhere forced retailers to reduce ranges and bring in imports at the expense of local suppliers. Products in-scope ran out. There were increased tensions in store. Small retailers lost out. Despite all this, price caps in Croatia, Hungary, France, and elsewhere did little to nothing to stop food inflation rises. This proposal is amongst the most ill-considered policies directed towards business to emanate from Holyrood in the past decade. It tramples all over the pledges in the Scottish Government’s legislative programme and New Deal for Business to ‘regulate last’ and involve commerce at the inception of policy development.

 

“Scots benefit from the most affordable food prices in Europe. That’s because we have, as the government’s own consultation acknowledges, a highly efficient and competitive grocery market. It’s time for Government to swallow some humble pie and ditch the cap. Instead of spending years, and millions of pounds, developing and enforcing a pointless policy, Scottish Minsters need to get to grips with the drivers and consequences of inflation. Scottish food and drink businesses want to help keep costs down for shoppers. It’s time Ministers focused on policies which will work, not empty populist soundbites.”

 

 

ENDS- 

Notes to Editors
The Scottish Retail Consortium’s Detailed Response to the consultation can be found here: https://brc.org.uk/media/2xen4mqf/src-response-to-the-scottish-government-consultation-on-price-controls-on-essential-goods.pdf


Our media team is here for you

We're ready to take questions from journalists and offer support and guidance to our members' press teams.