Milburn's Recommendations Published
Today (17th Nov), Milburn has published his final report on youth employment, setting out sweeping recommendations and fundamental system changes to reduce the number of young people not in education, employment or training.
Milburn predicts that his proposals, if implemented fully, would reduce the rate of young NEETs from 13% to 5% over the next decade. However, several billions of upfront costs will have to be found by government to make the changes, with savings only to be made through reduced welfare and increased tax receipts by 2036.
The Government has responded to the report this afternoon. They have broadly welcomed its findings and set out an intention to respond to it fully with a White Paper in the new year, followed by legislation enacting the changes from spring.
However, it is unclear whether they will accept the recommendations in full, meaning the BRC will be campaigning over the coming months for government to accept the recommendations that the retail industry would most value.
The recommendations are outlined in more detail below. Most are positive for the retail industry, but there are some areas of concern, especially when considering the potential impact on over-25s. Please reach out to Ben with your reflections and questions.
Background
Nearly 1 million young people are not in education, employment or training - around 13% of the population. The NEET level has barely fallen below 10% in the last 25 years.
Changes to the labour market are disproportionately impacting young people, with entry level vacancies falling 1.6x faster than the economy wide average.
Retail has faced spiraling employment costs since the 2024 Budget, with the industry seeing employment costs set to increase by a total of £8.5 billion from 2024 to 2027.
In this context, the Milburn report was commissioned by the Work and Pensions Secretary to put forward solutions to fix the broken system.
The interim diagnostic report was published earlier in the year, with the series of recommendations to address those diagnoses set out in today's report.
Government has worked closely with Milburn as he has written his report, and will respond in the coming weeks setting out which recommendations it will accept in further detail.
The Report - Key Headlines
Milburn sets out an overall ambition to reduce the NEET level from 13% to 5% over the next ten years. This equates to bringing about 600,000 young people into employment.
The measures set out within the report are estimated to create 440,000 job opportunities - with the suggestion that broader trends in the labour market as the new system develops would create further additional places to hit the 600,000 target.
The recommendations are not adding to or tweaking the current system - they represent a fundamental system change for young people, from early years, through education and into the workplace.
It is anticipated that the recommendations will require billions in upfront costs, but that savings could be made within ten years.
Employer National Insurance Contributions
Milburn is clear that employment costs have risen significantly in recent years, and that much of this has been caused by the changes to the employer National Insurance Contributions (both the rate at which it is paid, and the lowering of the threshold) at the 2024 Budget.
The lowering of the threshold disproportionately impacted sectors like retail where part-time jobs are much more prevalent.
Recommendation: a 'glide path' to increase the NICs threshold from £5,000 to £10,000 over the next five years.
Recommendation: implementation of this should be staggered, with efforts initially focused on the retail and hospitality industry.
Caveat: The Report suggests that these changes should only happen 'when fiscal conditions allow' - giving Treasury the opportunity to delay if they see fit.
BRC view: if implemented, this is a significant policy win for the retail industry which will substantially bring down the cost of hiring young people. We will pushing hard for the government to accept the recommendation and implement the changes as soon as possible.
National Living Wage/National Minimum Wage
The Labour 2024 manifesto committed to equalising the NLW and NMW over the course of the Parliament, essentially converging the rate for everyone over the age of 18.
Wage costs have for 18-20-year-olds have increased by 65% in the last five years, which, combined with other measures, has impacted hiring decisions.
Milburn is concerned that the convergence of the youth rate could disadvantage young people with less experience.
Recommendation: His support for increasing all wage rates by the same amount is made clear in the report, with a recommendation for the Low Pay Commission to continue to keenly consider youth employment when making its pay decisions.
Caveat: The report stops short of recommending that the pledge to converge the youth rate should be abandoned.
BRC View: We welcome Milburn's assessment and call on the government to consider retaining the youth rate in light of these recommendations.
Apprenticeships: Reform and Expansion
Milburn has pointed to apprenticeships as the top priority for education and skills to arise from his review.
The belief that apprenticeships should primarily be for young people is deep-rooted within his recommendations.
The below recommendations would contribute to the overarching aim of reaching 270,000 apprenticeships for young people each year.
Achievement rates will also need to increase from 65% to 80% if the completion target of 215,000 young people per year is to be achieved.
Recommendation: The Treasury 'top slice' of the Growth and Skills Levy should be abolished. Employers pay around £4 billion into the Levy each year, but the apprenticeship budget is only around £3 billion. Some money is allocated to devolved nations, but £460 million went back to the Treasury last year.
BRC view: We have long been calling for this practice to end, and this is a vindication for employers who had faced denial from government that this was taking place. All money that retailers pay into the Levy should be available for them to spend on apprenticeships.
Recommendation: To free up money for apprenticeships for young people, Milburn recommends requiring employers to contribute an additional 25% towards an apprenticeship for over-25s. This could increase further to 50% from 2031.
BRC view: This is a deeply concerning development which detracts from many of the positive suggestions in this review. Apprenticeship funding for all ages is crucial to upskill and reskill workers - it is employers' money and they should be free to spend it as they wish, and certainly shouldn't be required to pay twice. It also risks creating a cliff-edge at 25, where someone is heavily incentivised into a job at 24, and has all that support removed just months later.
Recommendation: the introduction of an initial 25,000 places onto a pre-apprenticeship. Aimed at 16-19-year-olds, and potentially delivered by colleges, this would aim to bridge the gap between education and employment by focusing on employability skills and work readiness.
BRC view: We have been calling for an employability apprenticeship unit so this is a welcome development. We would encourage government to accept the proposal and work closely with employers and the education sector in its construction.
Incentives for Employers
The simplification and expansion of current incentives for employers under the Youth Guarantee is put forward by Milburn.
The total up front cost of the incentives is expected to be £1.1billion per year - with the calculation that this should unlock 170,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities.
Recommendation: Employers who take on a young person who is NEET for over six months should receive £3,000. There should be an additional £2,000 for each qualifying person who is from a vulnerable group, such as care leavers or disabled people. Finally, small businesses (50 employees or fewer) should receive a further £2,000 subsidy.
BRC view: Employer incentives are welcome, but the navigation and administrative burden must be improved in order for these to work effectively.
Recommendation: A significant expansion of incentives for employers who bring a young person onto an apprenticeship. The current £2,000 incentive for non-Levy paying employers would be increased to £2,500 and also apply to Levy payers.
BRC view: Strongly welcome. This payment could help employer by substantially contributing to the costs associated with hiring and apprentice, such as backfilling roles for off-the-job training - something the BRC has long been campaigning on.
Employment Rights Act - Guaranteed Hours
Guaranteed hours is the biggest point of contention within the Employment Rights Act, with employers seriously concerned about the unintended consequences of overly stringent measures which go beyond the stated intention of tackling exploitative zero and low hours contracts.
Recommendation: Milburn argues that, whilst there are positives to improving worker security which should be pursued, he is concerned about the likelihood of negative implications for youth employment. He argues that 'a cautionary principle should be adopted' and that final decisions should be made with youth employment prospects at the forefront.
BRC view: We agree with Milburn that poor implementation of guaranteed hours will lead to negative impacts for young people by reducing the number of jobs that are available. If government wants to avoid this, it should ensure the measures are targeted at those on contracts of 8 hours or less.
New Legal Duties for Government
Milburn is clear that government must play a significant role in ensuring that opportunities are available to young people, and that support is provided to them both before and during their time in the workplace.
Recommendation: Youth Opportunity Test - government should test all new regulation against its potential impact on youth employment.
Recommendation: Youth Employment Cost Index - has a similar purpose, but with a specific focus on how employment costs associated with new regulations may impact hiring decisions.
Recommendation: Opportunity Guarantee - the principle that government should have a legal duty to provide young people with some form of opportunity to earn or learn. This principle overarches the new proposed opportunities through jobs, apprenticeships, etc.
Recommendation: Support Guarantee - further than the above, Milburn also proposes that there should be a legal duty for government to ensure there is appropriate support in place both before and during employment. This could be mental health support, careers coaching, or further support once in employment.
BRC view: We would be supportive of government ensuring it does its part to create the right conditions for increased youth employment. Any measures that are likely to adversely impact youth employment, such as guaranteed hours, should be considered in this light going forward.
Other headlines
A greater emphasis on employment support over welfare: Currently for every £1 spent on employment support, £25 is spent on benefits. Milburn hopes to reduce this ration to £1 : £2 by increasing employment support and eventually bringing down the welfare bill. He hopes to reduce the benefit bill by £3.6 billion per year by 2036 through these measures.
A Youth Opportunity Service: Delivery of the legal duties and other areas will be overseen by this service, which will function on a regional level. The idea is for a single front door which makes it easier for young people to engage with the system.
Some under 25s will lose support if they don't engage: it is clear that some young people may be worse off as a result of these proposals. Most notably, if a young person repeatedly refuses to engage with opportunities presented to them, they may lose the support they are receiving.
Milburn hopes improved youth participation will lead to savings: The key argument is that substantial upfront costs will be worth doing to increase employment, workforce participation and tax returns, meaning savings should be made within a decade.
Feedback or reflections?
Get in touch with me using the email address below.
































